Get in touch The reading shelf
I look at what each book claims and make the strongest case for its argument before checking the assumptions and evidence.
Why I Am a Catholic
Chesterton’s famous fence is not a command to keep every old rule. It is a demand to recover the missing reason before deciding what deserves to stay. This short reading note carries the idea into safety, trust, boundaries, habits and institutional memory.
Book I, Letter 2
The most repeated piece of advice in English, and nobody wrote it. “Well begun is half done” has no author — Horace is only the oldest named man with a book and a line number, and Plato and Aristotle both quote it as already old.
A Brief History of Humankind
The most quoted popular history of the century, taken one sentence at a time: that farming was “history’s biggest fraud,” that nothing social exists outside our common imagination, and that none of it made us happier. Thirty-six hidden axioms, and a verdict on each of them.
I focus on a sentence or passage that people often quote. The reading examines that argument in detail; it is not a review of the whole book.
What must be true for the argument to work? I state those assumptions in plain language and examine them separately. Where a study has a scorecard, you can follow each verdict back to the reasoning.
Before criticising an argument, I work through the best reasons for accepting it, including replies to the obvious objections. A criticism should address the strongest version of the claim.
I look at where the idea came from and what the author was responding to. That context helps explain the passage, but whether its claim is true still needs a separate answer.
